“Threw Him Away”

May 2, 2020

Starting a new job is confronting and disconcerting. The day before, you knew what you were doing, you were an ‘expert’. Now that you have been promoted or recruited, ironically, you’re clueless. You will definitely figure it all out, but the first few days constitute a crisis. Medicine is especially prone to that phenomenon and the accompanying anxiety that comes with moving one-step closer to the absolute responsibility for each patient’s well-being.



The State Medical Director for Organ and Tissue Donation was a very large step indeed. High profile and politically tricky, the unique part about donation was that without our community’s engagement, belief and trust in us, there was no donation. It wasn’t ‘my’ service, nor anyone else’s at DonateLife. We were merely the facilitators of a life-saving process that had no ceiling to its budget, no limit to the number of retrievals we could potentially do, except those set by the public’s willingness to donate part of themselves, to someone that they would never meet.


I witnessed my first organ retrieval as a houseman, looked after kidney transplant patients as a nephrology registrar, anaesthetised for organ retrieval and implantations and finally cared for donors and their relatives on intensive care unit. With increasing experience and fewer chance of surprises, comes a vague whiff of arrogance, even for the humblest of us. I was already an ICU Head of Department and now a whole Australian State’s solo representative on the national ‘Organ and Tissue Authority’.


I was practically a God and divinity can make social engagements particularly enjoyable, since our community holds a special place of mystery and intrigue for organ donation and transplantation.


“Do they take your organs before you’re dead?” took a bottle of Corona to dispel.


“Has anyone ever woken up after their heart was removed” took only a mouthful of nuts to deny.


Whereas “how come my relatives can overrule my decision to be a donor” could take a half bottle of wine to cover the legalities and the rationale. In fact the questioner needed the other half of the Sav Blanc to stay enthused.


It had only been a few weeks but I had it pretty much covered already. Our community knew so little about donation that even the range of questions was predictable and limited.


“Are you in charge of organ donation?” a lady asked as she approached me and my newly acquired sausage from the BBQ. I instinctively hoped this was the second “has ever anyone ever woken up…..” question. If it was, the sausage would outlast my answer.


“They threw my husband away.”


That was a first, as an opening gambit at a BBQ. The novelty of the introduction was in itself, disconcerting, irrespective of the images it conjured.


“He had a brain tumour. So they just threw him away.”


I gazed thoughtfully down into the heart of my sausage/bap/onion combo and wished it was a bottle of Gin.


“They never told us that he could have been a donor. Never asked us. Just dumped him in a hospice and waited for him to die.”


I tried to formulate an opening line through the beer, wine and nuts, still staring at my onions but missed my slot in the discussion.


“Me and my kids don’t get to go to any services of thanksgiving. Have him remembered for saving someone’s life.”


“Just threw him away.”


“Why didn’t they ask me?”


I sort of knew the medical answer to that conundrum, but from the other side, that reasoning didn’t stand up to scrutiny.


I would have to find answers for us both.


Red question marks blocking a blue arrow path between two rows of directional buttons
By Bruce Powell May 6, 2026
Experience teaches doctors how to stay calm when everything feels chaotic. High performance is often just structured thinking under pressure.
Hospital room with two beds and beige privacy curtains, white walls, and bright overhead lighting
By Bruce Powell May 5, 2026
A patient who can’t speak communicates perfectly. A reminder that listening is often the skill clinicians misunderstand, even when words are absent.
Selfie of a man with light curly hair and a white beard, making a playful face indoors.
By Bruce Powell May 5, 2026
Insight promises clarity, but it often destabilises identity. What happens when you see too much, too late, and can’t return to who you were.
Smiling person soaking in a bathtub with a white foam beard and wet spiky hair
By Bruce Powell April 27, 2026
Rethinking “bad behaviour” in brain injury: less about intent, more about control, shame, and the gap between clinical labels and lived reality.
Close-up of an arm with a small black abstract tattoo near the elbow.
By Bruce Powell April 25, 2026
NDIS access relies on executive function many applicants lack, turning support into a barrier. When paperwork decides outcomes, the system fails.
Large brown dog resting on a beige couch beside a black-and-white toy elephant
By Bruce Powell April 22, 2026
NDIS cuts risk shifting costs, not saving them. The issue is not spending less, but spending smarter on supports that change outcomes.
Black-and-white portrait of a man in a beret and zip-up jacket, looking straight ahead.
By Bruce Powell April 20, 2026
Saving lives is not the endpoint. Recovery is. This article examines how underpowered rehabilitation drives bed block, delays discharge, and weakens systems.
A watercolor painting of a rusted, white kettle with the red letters
By Bruce Powell April 8, 2026
Two convincing emails. One tax bill, one refund. Both felt real. Put the kettle on. Pause, step out, and avoid getting scammed.
A person wading in a clear, rocky tide pool at the base of a large, craggy mountain under a bright blue sky.
By Bruce Powell March 22, 2026
Rehabilitation is the missing link in Australia’s hospital crisis. Underfunding and COVID disruptions continue to block recovery and system flow.
A person with light-colored hair and facial hair sleeping peacefully on their side in a bed with white linens.
By Bruce Powell March 22, 2026
Featured in MJA InSight+, this article explores brain injury advocacy, the reality behind the Royal Commission findings, and why meaningful change is still overdue.
Show More